Provisional keep
8
Technically clean enough if biological reviewer agrees.
Human review
14
Diversity, context dependency, or reference-type judgment needed.
Replace
2
Risky for first freeze unless reviewer overrides.
Triage Summary
| Triage tier | Count | Freeze recommendation |
|---|---|---|
provisional_keep | 8 | Keep if biological reviewer agrees. |
human_review_context_dependency | 7 | Keep only if single-chain scoring remains interpretable. |
human_review_diversity | 6 | Keep only if antibody/Fab weighting is intentional. |
human_review_reference_type | 1 | Keep only if NMR reference is acceptable for this benchmark. |
replacement_recommended | 2 | Replace before freeze unless reviewer overrides. |
Provisional Keep Targets
13CZ:A, 13EE:A, 13FT:A, 9H8N:A, 9K9X:A, 9K9Y:A, 11BC:C, 12OY:A
These rows are now frozen as the Phase 1A SimpleFold-3B benchmark. This is a computational freeze, not biological approval.
Replacement Recommended
| Target | Reason |
|---|---|
9H8O:A | Low-resolution reference plus membrane/transport context. |
21VV:A | Low-resolution reference plus nucleosome, nonprotein, and complex context. |
Data
Boundary
This is a computational triage, not biological approval. Phase 1A is frozen for execution, but final biological interpretation remains blocked until a domain reviewer approves or caveats the 8-target set.